Advertisement

Holiday Baking Equipment Checklist Before You Start

Rimmed baking sheet lined with parchment

Before the holiday baking starts, run through a baking equipment checklist: a digital scale and measuring cups and spoons, the right pans in the sizes your recipes call for, rimmed sheet pans, parchment or silicone mats, cooling racks, an oven thermometer, a mixer, a bench scraper, piping bags and airtight tins. Checking now means no mid-recipe dash to the store.

You don’t need a lot of equipment. You need the right pieces, in working order, in the sizes your recipes expect.

Work through each section below with your cupboard open. Tick what you have, note what’s warped, rusty or missing, and you’ll have a short shopping list in 20 minutes.

Advertisement

Key takeaways

  • A digital scale is the single most useful baking tool; a cup of flour can vary a lot by volume.
  • Check pan sizes against your recipes: 9×13, 8- and 9-inch square, 9×5 loaf, 9-inch pie and 13×18 half sheet cover most holiday baking.
  • Lower the oven by 25°F when baking in glass, and watch cookies closely on dark sheets.
  • An oven thermometer tells you what the dial doesn’t.
  • Never taste raw dough or batter; raw flour can carry harmful bacteria.

Measuring tools

Most baking disappointments that aren’t about the oven are about measuring. Start here.

  • ☐ Digital kitchen scale that reads in grams and ounces, with a tare button and fresh batteries
  • ☐ Dry measuring cups in 1/4, 1/3, 1/2 and 1 cup, with flat rims for leveling
  • ☐ Liquid measuring cup, glass or clear plastic with a spout, 2-cup size at least
  • ☐ Measuring spoons, including 1/8 teaspoon if your set has it
  • ☐ Straight-edged spatula or knife for leveling

Why the scale comes first

King Arthur Baking calls cup measuring wildly inconsistent. Using its fluff-and-spoon method, a cup of all-purpose flour weighs around 120 grams, but densely packed flour can weigh up to 160 grams. That’s a third more flour than the recipe intended, which is enough to turn a tender cake dry.

If you stay with cups, fluff the flour, spoon it into the cup until it overflows, and scrape it level. Never scoop straight from the bag.

Pans and sheets

Pull every pan out and match it against your holiday recipes. A cake baked in the wrong size pan is thinner or deeper than intended, and the timing won’t work.

PanStandard sizeTypical holiday use
Rectangular cake pan9 x 13 inchesSheet cakes, bars, brownies, rolls
Square pans8 and 9 inchesFudge, brownies, snack cakes
Loaf pan9 x 5 inchesQuick breads, larger yeast loaves
Pie plate9 or 10 inches, about 1 1/2 inches deepPumpkin, pecan and apple pies
Half sheet pan13 x 18 inches, rimmedCookies, roasting, sheet-pan cakes

These standard sizes are from King Arthur Baking’s pan guide, which also notes that deep-dish pie pans run about 2 inches deep.

  • ☐ At least two rimmed half sheet pans, flat and not warped
  • ☐ Round cake pans, two of the same size, if you make layer cakes
  • ☐ Muffin tin, 12-cup
  • ☐ Tube or Bundt pan, if your recipes call for one
  • ☐ Springform pan for cheesecake, with a latch that still closes tight

Material matters

The same King Arthur guide explains that dark metal pans transfer heat faster than light ones and brown crusts faster, which helps pies but can scorch cookie bottoms. Glass is slower to heat but holds heat longer, so it recommends lowering the oven by 25°F when baking in glass. It suggests the same 25°F drop for dark nonstick cookie sheets.

It also points out a detail that trips people up: sheet pans have rims on all four sides, while cookie sheets have rims on only three so cookies slide off easily. Light, shiny surfaces help cookies brown evenly.

Set of measuring cups and spoons on a counter
Photo: Measuring cups (¼, ½, 1 cup) by Vimkay, BY-SA 4.0

Liners, racks and the oven itself

  • ☐ Parchment paper, a full roll, for lining pans and sheets
  • ☐ Silicone baking mats sized for your half sheets, clean and not stained sticky
  • ☐ Aluminum foil for pie shields and tenting
  • ☐ Two or more wire cooling racks, ideally ones that fit inside a half sheet pan
  • ☐ Oven thermometer that hangs or stands on the rack
  • ☐ Oven mitts without holes or thin spots

Parchment or silicone

Parchment is disposable and endlessly versatile: line cake pans, roll dough between sheets, make a quick piping cone. Silicone mats are reusable and give cookies a slightly softer, more even base. Wax paper isn’t the same thing; its coating isn’t meant for oven heat.

Check the oven, not just the pans

An oven’s dial and its actual temperature can differ, and you won’t know unless you measure. Put an oven thermometer in the center of the middle rack, heat the oven to 350°F, wait 20 minutes and read it. If it’s consistently off, adjust the dial to compensate and note the difference on a piece of tape.

Every recipe assumes your oven is telling the truth. Spend two minutes finding out whether it is.

Mixing and shaping tools

  • ☐ Stand mixer or hand mixer, with beaters and paddle that aren’t bent
  • ☐ Mixing bowls in three sizes, at least one heatproof
  • ☐ Silicone spatulas, one large and one narrow for jars
  • ☐ Balloon whisk
  • ☐ Bench scraper for dividing dough and cleaning the counter
  • ☐ Rolling pin
  • ☐ Pastry brush for egg washes and glazes
  • ☐ Cookie scoops in one or two sizes for even cookies
  • ☐ Fine-mesh sieve for sifting and dusting
  • ☐ Instant-read thermometer for custards, breads and candy

A hand mixer handles most cookie doughs and whipped cream. A stand mixer earns its space if you make bread, big batches or stiff meringues. Whichever you have, run it for a minute to be sure the motor sounds healthy.

A bench scraper is the most underrated tool on this list. It cuts dough cleanly, lifts rolled pastry and scrapes the counter clear of flour in seconds.

Decorating and storage

  • ☐ Piping bags, disposable or reusable, plus couplers
  • ☐ Piping tips: a plain round and a star tip cover most jobs
  • ☐ Offset spatula for frosting and lifting cookies
  • ☐ Cookie cutters, checked for bent edges
  • ☐ Airtight tins or containers for storing and gifting
  • ☐ Wax paper or parchment to layer cookies in tins

Store crisp and soft cookies in separate tins. Soft cookies give off moisture that turns crisp ones limp. Let everything cool completely before the lid goes on, or condensation will do the same damage.

If you’re planning a cookie swap, our holiday cookie recipes are a good place to start.

Cookies cooling on a wire rack
Photo: Double choc chip cookies on the cooling rack (9505795812) by Ruth Hartnup from Vancouver, Canada, BY 2.0

A clean start: food safety for bakers

Holiday baking means a lot of raw flour and eggs in a busy kitchen. The FDA says to never eat or taste raw flour, dough or batter, because grains are grown outdoors and flour can carry bacteria like Salmonella and pathogenic E. coli. Cooking is what makes it safe.

  • ☐ Keep raw flour and eggs separate from ready-to-eat foods, like frosting and toppings
  • ☐ Wash hands with soap and running water after handling flour and raw eggs
  • ☐ Wash bowls, utensils, pans and counters in warm, soapy water after use
  • ☐ Skip adding raw cookie dough to ice cream or milkshakes at home

FAQ

What’s the one thing to buy if I’m missing a lot?

A digital scale. It improves nearly every recipe and makes cleanup faster, since you can measure straight into one bowl.

Can I use a 9-inch pan instead of an 8-inch one?

Yes, but the batter will be thinner and bake faster. Start checking several minutes early.

Do I really need two sheet pans?

It helps a lot. You can load one while the other bakes, and always put cookie dough onto a cool pan so it doesn’t spread early.

How do I know if a pan is too warped to use?

Set it on the counter and press each corner. If it rocks or spins, it’ll bake unevenly.

Do the checklist this weekend

Set aside 20 minutes this weekend, pull everything out, and go through the checklist section by section. Recycle what’s warped, write down what’s missing, and buy it before the first recipe of the season. For more on tools, browse our kitchen gear guides or read choosing a stand mixer.

Featured photo: Cranberry-Mohn Muffins in baking tray by Katrin Morenz, BY-SA 2.0.

Advertisement


More stories

Advertisement

Sections

Advertisement